StudentsReview :: Carnegie Mellon University - Comments and Student Experiences
Search for Schools by Region

or within distance of city

Similar Schools
Cornell University -- Ithaca, NY
Massachusetts Institute of Technology -- Cambridge, MA
Harvard University -- Cambridge, MA

  Who's got the Best?

Perceptual Rankings:
You Make 'Em.
We Post 'Em.
You Vote 'Em Up.
You Vote 'Em Down.
Aww yeah.

Carnegie Mellon University

Select Comment

Positive Neutral Negative Advice

There are 20 Comments

Sort By: [Date] [Major] [Rating]  


The academics are really overrated and they expect

May 31 2013Electrical Engineering
The academics are really overrated and they expect you to figure everything out by yourself, and the tests are nothing like homework or quiz problems. There is zero social life, almost everyone is ugly and the entire atmosphere is one of doom and gloom, which ended up hurting my grades substantially because I was always depressed. Hell, there was even an article about it in the school newspaper that sparked a lot of discussion that got nothing done. Pittsburgh is ok but if you want to explore it you'll probably end up doing it alone. Really only come here if you're content with studying 24/7 with no fun all for a mediocre GPA, or you'll hate your life like everyone else here does.
2nd Year Male -- Class 2015
Useful Schoolwork: A-, Individual Value: F

Architecture is viewed as a time-intensive and difficult

Jan 22 2011Architecture
Architecture is viewed as a time-intensive and difficult major at this university but the work and the disrespectful attitudes of some professors and faculty members make it even more difficult. More than half of the people in the program have left it and of the ones that are left, most have developed a very defeatist attitude about being truly happy or well-rounded or being treated with respect. I'm very disappointed with some of the faculty in this program, although others are gems.
3rd Year Female -- Class 2013
Perceived Campus Safety: A, Education Quality: D

Senior year of high school, Carnegie Mellon was

Mar 15 2011Mechanical Engineering
Senior year of high school, Carnegie Mellon was my dream school. I'm not sure why, in retrospect.
I try very hard at this school. I give it my all and I never procrastinate, despite never having had to in high school. However, it never seems to be enough. My GPA is barely over a 3.0, although I devote huge amounts of time to working myself ragged, studying, and the like. I wish I had more time to simply enjoy myself but that's not possible here.

Much of the learning is "do it yourself." The lectures are alright to follow, but the homeworks and exams are given with the assumption that you're a brilliant genius. I spend most of my life in office hours just trying to do a few problems. Most of my time is spent trying to figure out how to do problem sets. (Also: Any programming course is taught as if you are a computer science major, which bothers me, as this is the top school for CS. I spend about 15 hours per weekend programming.)

The academic workload has been a direct precipitant to mental breakdowns for many people I know. And not just in engineering. This goes for CS, Art, Architechture, the Sciences, math, and business.

The dorms are pretty horrible. Excluding 1 or 2, they are dingy, and poorly kept, and occasionally tiny.

I often feel like CMU tries to suck the money out of its kids. Every year, rates for something go up. It's one of the priciest schools to attend. I have been forced to go off the meal plan, go off of campus housing, and still take out huge loans to come here.

Males are very unattractive. 90% (no exaggeration) of them look prepubescent, pale, or pimply. A few exceptions exist. Females are maybe 35 - 40% attractive, so that's not too bad. But again, there are few females.

The WORST part: social life is pretty horrible. I hoped to make friends, but literally, I have none. If you are unable to make friends in your major or first year dorm, you're essentially screwed for the rest of the time. I slipped through the cracks freshman year, and I'm incredibly lonely. I've found that engineers here (and in general) are very bland, socially. It's difficult for me to relate to other engineers/technical field people. I know too many people in a similar situation.

But, if you're a girl and happen to find a decent guy, people here tend to like relationships (as opposed to promiscuity and exorbitant hooking up). That's kind of a plus?

Pittsburgh isn't horrible. It caters well to college students. Stuff within walking distance, buses, etc. No shopping unfortunately.

Conclusion: I wouldn't recommend coming to CMU. Only if you make a solid group of friends, then it might be tolerable. But if you do make friends, your GPA will be horrible, even if you get no sleep.

I hold a deep and bitter resentment towards CMU. I will never give back. Most people hate it. And if you look at the rate of Alumni giving, you will see that reflected in the very low giving percentages. For good reason.

I will say, however, that CMU provides decent career resources and networking opportunities (for technical fields at least).

2nd Year Female -- Class 2013
Friendliness: A-, Scholastic Success: F
Carnegie Mellon University
Carnegie Mellon University
About Us | Advertise! | Press
Send Comments/Suggestions to:

Copyright © 2000-2014. StudentsReview, All Rights Reserved.


Disclaimer: StudentsReview makes no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the contents of this site, and expressly disclaims liability for errors and omissions in the contents of this site. Furthermore, StudentsReview is not affiliated with any University or Institution.

All Universities in Pennsylvania (PA), College Search, College Rankings