I
want to start this comment by stating that I am
obviously biased, as my harsh grading of Cornell University would
demonstrate. That being said, I am striving to be as
objective and impartial as possible, so I will not be
going on any tirades against Cornell. Instead, I am going
to discuss what happened to me when I was there
and let you sort it out for yourself. I started
at Cornell as a straight A student. My high school
GPA was 4.0, I had tons of community service, and
I was the captain of my rowing team. I was
kicking butt and taking names. Big deal, so is everyone
at Cornell. I'm writing this not for props or to
say I'm a special case. Quite the contrary, I'm establishing
that I am a typical Cornellian. I did, however, lack
the attitude of elitism that seems to characterize Cornell students
(and Ivy League students in general). I have never understood
this sense of elitism, because at least while the students
are still that—students, not alumni—they certainly haven't earned any exclusive
bragging rights. And I suspect that they haven't earned any
particular bragging rights by having completed the curricula of their
various institutions.
That is, however, neither here nor there. My
point is simply that I entered this institution as an
A+ student, an athlete, a healthy person, and a social
person. What I was confronted with upon getting to Cornell
was a very bleak living situation in which people did
not want to spend a minute getting to know you
if you were not interested in drinking or doing drugs.
I met several kids in my later years at
who actually bragged about how they used cocaine as a
study aide. I don't know what to say to people
like that. That's pretty astonishing. I hope they aren't planning
to pass a drug screening test at any point in
their professional lives.
I suppose it is not altogether surprising
to get to a university and see no shortage of
drunken revelry. Cornell actually has an entire day dedicated to
this very thing, which is vaguely reminiscent of the debacle
that is Oktoberfest. Midwesterners, you know what I'm talking about,
especially Wisconsonians! This day is called Slope Day, and it
is a 'celebration' (read: cheap excuse to consume libations) of
the last day of the academic year.
It is understandable
that students would want to relax after such a pulverizing
workload. Cornell loves to load you up. And I often
questioned if it was worthwhile learning. Many times it seemed
like reading a lot of books simply for the sake
of reading a lot of books. What was the point
of studying 20 novels in a writing course if each
novel was given a measly one or two classes of
individual treatment. What do you really get out of a
15 minute group conversation where every student is mandated via
class participation points to say something about the text, nevermind
how irrelevant? And what is up with class participation points
anyway? Why don't they let Ivy League students wear the
big boy pants and sink or swim based on their
test scores and essays? I mean most of us didn't
have participation points in high school, so why the regression
to such juvenile tools of academic fear mongering?
And speaking
of regression, that is precisely what shocked me the most
about Cornell. Perhaps I'm abnormal here, but as an overachiever
in and out of my academic life, I have always
been sort of the odd man out in my circles
of friends. I'm frequently getting, “Woah, big words, duuuude” comments
from my peers. My whole life I was assured by
adults that things get better in college, probably because when
they went to college that was true. However, in this
case it was quite the contrary. Students seemed to be
entirely beholden to ethyl alcohol. The same students I saw
frequently hung over or high were getting straight A's. At
first, I thought “Wow, they're SO much smarter than I
am that they can do this stuff and still ace
everything.” Then I started paying closer attention and I'd notice
that the same group of stoners and drunks would always
sit a liiiittle too close together come test time. Or
that they sure seemed to get a lot of cell
phone 'calls' (read: text messages) during tests.
I have my
suspicions of cheating for a long time, but then I
had it confirmed on two separate occasions. The first was
when at a Marketing final exam, the professor (stupidly) handed
out 3 tests on 3 different colored papers. A yellow,
a pink, and a green. The tests were shuffled so
they were handed out in that order...yellow, pink, green. But
mysteriously in the midst of all of this, 3 people
in a row managed to have yellow, and a little
while later 3 had pink, and a little while later
3 had green. Hmmmm.
If that doesn't do it for
you, then my senior year, the Student Government at Cornell
petitioned the faculty to help them create a special commission
for academic integrity to confront the rampant cheating that had
been uncovered on campus. It turns out that there are
not just individual cheaters at Cornell, but actual cheating cartels.
Yes, seriously, it is such a cut-throat learning environment that
not only are people cheating to get ahead (and I
hope they can sleep well knowing what they have done),
they are actually forming entire networks of students who are
cooperating to screw over everyone else. I'll give you one
example: TakeNote. TakeNote is a professional note taking service that
offers you notes taken, typed up, and prepared by graduate
students for all of the general education classes like Bio
101, Chem 207, etc. The catch is that of course
TakeNote wants to protect its assets, so it prepares all
of its notes on red paper with black text. It's
still very easy to read, but it's impossible (or at
least very difficult) to photocopy it in any sort of
legible format.
HOWEVER, TakeNote gives a copy or two of
its notes to the libraries (there's 7 or 8
of them, which IS impressive, and I did rate Cornell
as top notch for resources for learning), and the libraries
allow students to check them out for something like 90
minutes at a time. What the cheating cartels at Cornell
University like to do is starting two or three weeks
before an exam, check out all of the TakeNote notes,
as well as the textbooks for the class and any
teacher's manual copies of those texts and any texts that
could be relevant for studying the topic in question. They
will get as many people as needed to check these
resources out and keep them checked out until after the
exam.
Now before you claim that I'm being paranoid and
mistaking a rush of studious students to get limited resources,
let me be clear: the student government did a full
expose on this system of cheating and showed irrefutable evidence
that it was the same people doing this over and
over again with organized, malicious intent.
Can you study your
own notes and get an A? Sure! But would it
help to see the notes of another person who has
graciously made their notes available for the perusal of interested
students? Indubitably! And this is just one form of cheating
that goes on at Cornell. Cheating is a major part
of the system at Cornell.
I could go on and
on about the negative things at Cornell, but I'll just
finish my story.
So I came in as an A+
student, did alright my first year, making straight A's, but
then broke both of my wrists AND contracted mononucleosis within
the span of about a month. Well, there went my
rowing career. I WAS on the team and was in
the A boat at the time, but the coach told
me that since I was going to be barred from
going to spring training due to my injury, that I
would be bumped to the B boat, which meant I
wouldn't be racing, basically.
The professors at Cornell were somewhat
understanding of my condition, and did allow me some time
away from school to recuperate, but as a result of
mono, I developed progressive sleep apnea. Long story short, I
slogged through 3 more years of school suffering from sleep
deprivation and deteriorating health with no sympathy from my dean,
no assistance from any of my professors, and little in
the way of common ground or fellowship with my fellow
students.
I did graduate on time, which was a blessing,
but by the time I got out of Cornell, I
had become so frustrated by the red tape involved in
getting ANYTHING done—you name it, course add, course drop, parking
permits, contacting professors, office hours, everything!—that I just wanted to
leave. But by the time I was that far in,
I wanted my Nike swoosh diploma. Well, I thought I
was getting one anyway. Turns out I've only once in
3 years of applying to jobs heard someone say “Oh
wow, a Cornell man! Of course you can come for
an interview!” I didn't expect the WORLD from a Cornell
degree, but I did expect an entry level job at
the very least.
AND I expected assistance in finding a
job from the alumni association and the career counseling office.
The latter has never helped me find any job listing
in any city big or small that I've lived in—and
I've lived in Oahu, Hawaii, Pittsburgh, PA, and little old
La Crosse, WI—and the former gave me one contact once,
who grudgingly agreed to give me a job lead that
ended up wanting to pay me minimum wage to conduct
cancer research. I ended up turning the job down to
take another job at a different cancer research lab that
at least paid me $8.50.
Perhaps my idea of what
Ivy League colleges could do for their alumni was overinflated.
If that's the case, then you can discount what I'm
saying in this statement. However, if you have a similar
idea in mind about your diploma being worth more because
it's an Ivy League, forget about it. I've never had
medical schools jump at me because I was an Ivy
Leaguer. I've never had employers jump at it. I haven't
even had graduate schools jump at it. It's humdrum. What
they care about is your GPA.
SO, to that end,
I recommend that you only go to an Ivy League
if you are somewhat of an elitist, are not remotely
religious (because Ivy Leagues thrive on crushing the religion out
of you, but I feel that is a subject for
a different forum!), and know for sure you can get
a 4.0. If any of these 3 is not true
of you, then for the sake of your own future
employability and happiness, will you please consider going to a
smaller school where you will get a 4.0 easily and
will have access to friendlier staff and faculty who will
assist you in getting a phenomenal internship or externship? You'll
be glad you did. I know because this is precisely
what I did with my graduate education, choosing to go
to Duquesne University in Pittsburgh, PA because of its small
size and friendly atmosphere. I was placed in two different
excellent internships that have lead to employment in the healthcare
industry and an interview at a major medical school on
November 25th. Cornell has done nothing to help with any
of that. It's all been Duquesne. Heck, I should go
write a review for Duquesne next!
So in closing, I
don't mean to trash everything about . It's a beautiful
campus. The bus system is fantastic. If you're into 'partying',
College Town is perfect for you. Get an apartment there
sophomore year and have a blast. The surrounding area is
GORGEOUS, with lots of natural gorges cut out by the
rivers in the area.
Ithaca, NY, the locus of Cornell,
is a fun town to tool around in, too. They
have some EXCELLENT cuisine. Thai Cuisine is the best dog
gone Thai restaurant outside of Thailand, hands down. The Wegman's
in downtown Ithaca has a great variety of produce, and
probably has a huge organic section now, too, since that's
begun to be more popular. There are all kinds of
cultural events to go to both on and off campus.
The athletics is pretty good, except the football team which
can't seem to do anything right. The quality of the
food is fantastic, and I'm hoping the middlle-aged Asian couple
still works at Appel Commons serving up Asian cuisine M-F.
They were a constant source of merriment and memories.
But
for all the amenities and trappings of a ritzy Ivy
League (and it IS ritzy; I was friends with the
daughter of the gentleman who owns slightly less of the
Hilton franchise than Mr. Hilton himself, Emeril Legassi's daughter was
a classmate, and there were rumors that a Dubai oil
baron's daughter was attending Cornell incognito), the cut-throat academic spirit
and the lack of caring on the part of the
professors really puts a damper on this university. I'd rather
have high quality relationships with faculty and low quality living
conditions than vice versa. Maybe that's just me. If you
can handle the latter, then is the place for
you, and God bless you on your academic journey.
Disclaimer:
The author of this commentary, David Stratton, intends this commentary
only for his personal use. It is in no way,
shape, or form to be construed as advice to persons
other than Mr. Stratton, and any use of this information
as such is entirely without consequence to Mr. Stratton. Mr.
Stratton is, by dint of this disclaimer, hereby indemnified from
any claims of libel, slander, or malicious intent from Cornell
University, Inc. or any of its affiliates. God bless you,
and God bless the Constitution!